The HP_ALIGN Pragma

If only one alignment mode is used throughout the entire file, this pragma is straightforward to use and to understand. However, when a different mode is introduced in the middle of the file, you should be aware of its implications and effects.

The key to understanding HP_ALIGN is the following concept: typedefs and struct or union types retain their original alignment mode throughout the entire file. Therefore, when a type with one alignment is used in a different alignment mode, it will still keep its original alignment.

This feature may lead to confusion when you have a typedef, structure or union of one alignment nested inside a typedef, structure or union of another alignment.

Here are some examples of the most common misunderstandings.

Example 1: Using Typedefs

The alignment pragma will affect typedef, struct, and union types. Therefore, in the following declaration:

#pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD typedef int int32;

int32 is not equivalent to int. To illustrate:

#pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD typedef int int32; void routine (int *x); int main() { int *ok; int32 *bad; routine(ok); routine(bad); /* warning */ }

Compiling this with -Aa -c will give two warnings:

warning 604: Pointers are not assignment-compatible. warning 563: Argument #1 is not the correct type.

These warnings occur because the actual pointer value of bad may not be as strictly aligned as the pointer type routine expects. This may lead to run-time bus errors in the called function if it dereferences the misaligned pointer.

Example 2: Using Combination of Different Alignment Modes

In the WORD alignment modes, the members of a structure whose sizes are larger than 2 bytes are aligned on a 2-byte boundary. However, this is only true if those member types are scalar or have been previously declared under the same alignment mode. If the member type is a typedef, struct, or union type which has been declared previously under a different alignment mode, it will retain its original alignment, regardless of current alignment mode in effect. For example:

typedef int my_int; #pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD struct st { char c; my_int i; }; int main() { char c; struct st foo; }

Although the size of my_int is greater than 2 bytes, because it was declared previously under HPUX_NATURAL with the alignment of 4 bytes it will be aligned on a 4-byte boundary, causing the entire struct st to be aligned on a 4-byte boundary. Compiling with the +m option to show the offsets of the identifiers (offsets given as "byte-offset @ bit-offset" in hexadecimal), you will get the following output:

main Identifier Class Type Address - - - c auto char SP-48 foo auto struct st SP-44 c member char 0x0 @ 0x0 i member int 0x4 @ 0x0

The resulting size of foo is 8 bytes, with 4-byte alignment.

If you change the type of member i in struct st to be a simple int type, then you will get the following result:

main Identifier Class Type Address - - c auto char SP-40 foo auto struct st SP-38 c member char 0x0 @ 0x0 i member int 0x2 @ 0x0

This time, the resulting size of foo is 6 bytes, with 2-byte alignment.

Example 3: Incorrect Use of Typedefs and Alignments

Often, you might mix typedefs and alignments without being aware of the actual alignment of the data types.

What may appear to be correct usages of these data types may turn out to be causes for misaligned pointers and run-time bus errors, among other things. For example, consider the following program.

<my_include.h> typedef unsigned short ushort; extern int get_index(void); extern ushort get_value(void); <my_prog.c> #include "my_include.h" #pragma HP_ALIGN NOPADDING PUSH struct s { ushort member1; ushort member2; }; #pragma HP_ALIGN POP char myBuffer[100]; int main() { struct s *my_struct; int index = get_index(); int value = get_value(); int not_done = 1; while (not_done) { my_struct = (struct s*)&myBuffer[index]; my_struct->member1 = value; . . . } }

This code is not written safely. Although struct s is declared under NOPADDING alignment mode, it has 2-byte alignment due to the typedef for ushort. However, a pointer to struct s can be assigned an address that can point to anywhere in the char array (including odd addresses). If the function get_index always returns an even number, you will not run into any problems, because it will always be 2-byte aligned. However, if the index happens to be an odd number, &myBuffer[index] will be an odd address. Dereferencing that pointer to store into a 2-byte aligned member will result in a run-time bus error.

Below are some examples of what you can do to avoid such behavior.

• Compile with +u1 option, which forces all pointer dereferences to assume that data is aligned on 1-byte boundaries. However, this will have a negative impact on performance.

• Put the typedef inside the NOPADDING alignment. However, if you use ushort in contexts where it must have 2-byte alignment, this may not be what you want.

• Declare struct s with the basic type unsigned short rather than the typedef ushort.

• Make sure that the pointer will always be 2-byte aligned by returning an even index into the char array.

• Declare another typedef for ushort under the NOPADDING alignment:

  typedef ushort ushort_1

  and use the new type ushort_1 inside struct s.

As mentioned above, the HP_ALIGN pragma must have a global scope; it must be outside of any function or enclosing structure or union. For example, suppose you have the following sequence of pragmas:

#pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD PUSH struct string_1 { char *c_string; int counter; }; #pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_NATURAL PUSH struct car { long double car_speed; char *car_type; }; #pragma HP_ALIGN POP struct bus { int bus_number; char bus_color; }; #pragma HP_ALIGN POP

Variables declared of type struct string_1, are aligned according to the HPUX_WORD alignment mode. Variables declared of type struct car, are aligned according to the HPUX_NATURAL alignment mode. Variables declared of type struct bus are aligned according to HPUX_WORD.

Be careful when using pointers to access non-natively aligned data types within structures and unions. Alignment information is significant, as pointers may be dereferenced with either 8-bit, 16-bit, or 32-bit machine instructions. Dereferencing a pointer with an incompatible machine instruction usually results in a run-time error.

HP C permanently changes the size and alignment information of typedefs defined within the scope of an HP_ALIGN pragma. It makes data objects, such as pointers, declared by using typedefs, compatible with similar objects defined within the scope of the pragma.

For example, a pointer to an integer type declared with a typedef that is affected by the HP_ALIGN pragma will be dereferenced safely when it points to an integer object whose alignment is the same as that specified in the pragma.

The typedef alignment information is persistent outside the scope of the HP_ALIGN pragma. An object declared with a typedef will have the same storage and alignment as all other objects declared with the same typedef, regardless of the location of other HP_ALIGN pragma statements in the program.

There is a slight performance penalty for using non-native data alignments. The compiler generates slower but safe code for dereferencing non-natively aligned data. It generates more efficient code for natively aligned data.

The following program generates a run-time error because a pointer that expects word-aligned data is used to access a half-word aligned item:

#pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD
 
struct t1 { char a; int b;} non_native_rec;
 
#pragma HP_ALIGN POP
 
main ()
{
        int i;
        int *p = &non_native_rec.b;
        i  = *p;  /* assignment causes run-time bus error */
}

The following program works as expected because the pointer has the same alignment as the structure:

#pragma HP_ALIGN HPUX_WORD
 
struct t1 { char a; int b;} non_native_rec;
typedef int non_native_int;
 
#pragma HP_ALIGN POP
 
main ()
{
        int i;
        non_native_int *p = &non_native_rec.b;
        i = *p;
}

An alternative to using the HP_ALIGN pragma and typedefs to control non-natively aligned pointers is to use the +ubytes compiler option of HP C/HP-UX. The +ubytes forces all pointer dereferences to assume that data is aligned on 8-bit, 16-bit, or 32-bit addresses. The value of bytes can be 1 (8-bit), 2 (16-bit), or 4 (32-bit). This option can be used when accessing non-natively aligned data with pointers that would otherwise be natively aligned. This option can be useful with code that generates the compiler warning message

#565 - "address operator applied to non natively aligned member."

and aborts with a run-time error.

The +ubytes option affects all pointer dereferences within the source file. It can have a noticeable, negative impact on performance.

	NOTE: The HP C/iX implementation of the +u option omits the bytes parameter.